What If Confederacy Won


What If Confederacy Won?

A successful Confederacy would be a zero-sum economy. In the world of Confederate the economy would be a hierarchy with no social mobility since mobility among economic classes would open the door to economic mobility across racial lines.Jul 31 2017

Could the Confederacy have won?

Put in a logical way in order for the North to win the Civil War it had to gain total military victory over the Confederacy. The South could win the war either by gaining military victory of its own or simply by continuing to exist. … As long as the South remained out of the Union it was winning.

What if the South won the Civil War alternate history?

If the South Had Won the Civil War is a 1961 alternate history book by MacKinlay Kantor a writer who also wrote several novels about the American Civil War as it actually happened. … Later writers of such books such as Harry Turtledove explicitly stated Kantor’s influence on their own work.

What would the world look like if the South had won?

Was the Confederacy ever close to winning?

Early in the American Civil War the Confederacy almost won. It was not the complete victory the Union eventually achieved. Rather than conquering their opponents the Confederates hoped to force them to the negotiating table where the division of the states could be accomplished.

Was Confederate defeat inevitable?

A Confederate victory through Lincoln’s defeat at the ballot box in November 1864 was entirely plausible. “Even [at the end of 1863] defeat was not yet inevitable ” explains Richard McMurry. “If the Confederates could hold on they might convince the northern public that victory was not worth what it would cost.

Why did the Confederacy lose?

Explanations for Confederate defeat in the Civil War can be broken into two categories: some historians argue that the Confederacy collapsed largely because of social divisions within Southern society while others emphasize the Union’s military defeat of Confederate armies.

Would slavery still exist if the South won?

First had the Confederacy won the Civil War slavery would have undoubtedly continued in the South. As a result of the Emancipation Proclamation and the Union victory slavery was abolished. … A victory by the North did equate to the end of slavery. A victory by the South would have meant the opposite.

Would the South have ended slavery?

With slavery being so central to the Confederate cause economy and social structure it is unlikely that slavery could have been abolished within the near future after secession. … First the concentration of slavery was gradually moving southward as years of cotton planting had depleted the soil of the Upper South.

What would have happened if Lee won Gettysburg?

One historian believes the battle between Confederate General Robert E. Lee and the Union’s Army of the Potomac led by General George Meade truly was decisive “If Lee had been victorious the Army of the Potomac would have dissolved ” said Alan Guelzo history professor at Gettysburg College and author the new book ” …

Did Mexico support the Confederacy?

Mexican Americans who joined the Confederacy fought as far away as Virginia and Pennsylvania. But Mexican American soldiers in the Union fought closer to home and helped secure key victories in the southwest.

See also who discovered cell and how

How long would slavery have lasted in the south?

If the South Had Won the Civil War Slavery Could Have Lasted Until the 20th Century.

Why did the Confederacy think they could win?

First the southern leaders were sure the north was not going to have a full-scale military conflict. … They thought that a compromise and peace agreement could be reached after a short period of fighting. Second the south was going to fight a defensive war.

Did the Confederacy win any battles?

Known in the north as the Battle of Bull Run and in the South as the Battle of Manassas this battle fought on July 21 1861 in Virginia was the first major battle of the Civil War. It was a Confederate victory.

Why did the South lose the Civil War?

The most convincing ‘internal’ factor behind southern defeat was the very institution that prompted secession: slavery. Enslaved people fled to join the Union army depriving the South of labour and strengthening the North by more than 100 000 soldiers. Even so slavery was not in itself the cause of defeat.

Did the South really lose the Civil War?

After four bloody years of conflict the United States defeated the Confederate States. In the end the states that were in rebellion were readmitted to the United States and the institution of slavery was abolished nation-wide.

Was the Civil war bad?

The conflict was the costliest and deadliest war ever fought on American soil with some 620 000 of 2.4 million soldiers killed millions more injured and much of the South left in ruin.

What ended the civil war?

April 12 1861 – April 9 1865

See also How Are Levees Beneficial To Human Settlements??

Why Lee lost at Gettysburg?

The two reasons that are most widely accepted as determining the outcome of the battle are the Union’s tactical advantage (due to the occupation of the high ground) and the absence of J.E.B. Stuart’s Confederate cavalry on the first day of fighting.

How was the Confederacy finally defeated?

The Confederacy was finally defeated at the Appomattox Courthouse when General Robert E. Lee surrendered. The Union forces destroyed the South’s will to carry on the fight when the Union blocked his escape route. He realized further bloodshed was futile and surrendered.

Was Robert E Lee a good American?

After his death in 1870 Lee became a cultural icon in the South and is largely hailed as one of the Civil War’s greatest generals. As commander of the Army of Northern Virginia he fought most of his battles against armies of significantly larger size and managed to win many of them.

Why did North win civil war?

Possible Contributors to the North’s Victory:

The North was more industrial and produced 94 percent of the USA’s pig iron and 97 percent of its firearms. The North even had a richer more varied agriculture than the South. The Union had a larger navy blocking all efforts from the Confederacy to trade with Europe.

Could the Civil War have been avoided?

The only compromise that could have headed off war by then was for the Southern states to forgo secession and agree to abolition. … Once the Confederate states seceded and troops fired on Fort Sumter the only solution possible was complete Southern surrender.

What was the average Confederate soldier fighting for?

Common sentiments for supporting the Confederate cause during the Civil War were slavery and states’ rights. These motivations played a part in the lives of Confederate soldiers and the South’s decision to withdraw from the Union. Many were motivated to fight in order to preserve the institution of slavery.

Do you believe that the Civil War was inevitable?

Was the Civil War inevitable? Yes. Up until the Southern states seceded and formed a Confederacy the Civil War was not inevitable. Even with the Force Act there was no guarantee that the Union would decide to actually use force to bring the Southern states back.

What were Confederates fighting for?

The Confederate States Army also called the Confederate Army or simply the Southern Army was the military land force of the Confederate States of America (commonly referred to as the Confederacy) during the American Civil War (1861–1865) fighting against the United States forces in order to uphold the institution of

Why was the North opposed to slavery?

Attitudes to slavery – North and South

For many years there was an uneasy alliance between the Northern free states and the Southern slave states. This was not to last for long. As more people from both the North and the South were moving west the issue of slavery started to create problems.

See also what is the genotype of the parent with orange eyes and white skin

What are the 3 main causes of the Civil War?

Below we will discuss the impact slavery had in leading up to the war as well as some of the differences between the two sides that led to such a great divide. At the heart of the divide between the North and the South was slavery. The South relied on slavery for labor to work the fields.

What would have happened if the South won the Civil War?

First the outcome of the victory of the South could have been another Union ruled by the Southern States. The United-States of America would have another capital in Richmond. … Their industrious prosperity would have been stopped and slavery would have remained in all the United-States for a long time.

What if the Confederacy had won at Gettysburg?

If General James Longstreet had commanded the Confederate forces at Gettysburg instead of Lee the Confederacy might very well have won the Civil War. The outcome of a Confederate victory would have been the break up of the United States but not quite as President Jeff Davis wanted.

Could the South have won at Gettysburg?

The Union had won the Battle of Gettysburg. … Union casualties in the battle numbered 23 000 while the Confederates had lost some 28 000 men–more than a third of Lee’s army. The North rejoiced while the South mourned its hopes for foreign recognition of the Confederacy erased.

Did any countries support the Confederacy?

Every nation was officially neutral throughout the war and none formally recognized the Confederacy. The major nations all recognized that the Confederacy had certain rights as an organized belligerent. … British leaders had some sympathy for the Confederacy but were never willing to risk war with the Union.

Did Texas fight in the Civil War?

Some Texan military units fought in the Civil War east of the Mississippi River but Texas was more useful for supplying soldiers and horses for the Confederate Army.

Texas in the American Civil War.
Largest city Houston
Admitted to the Confederacy March 23 1861 (4th)
Population 604 215 total • 421 649 free • 182 566 slave

Did France fight in the Civil War?

The Second French Empire remained officially neutral throughout the American Civil War and never recognized the Confederate States of America. The United States warned that recognition would mean war. France was reluctant to act without British collaboration and the British government rejected intervention.

What if the South won the Civil War?

What if the South Won the American Civil War?

The Alternate World of A Southern Victory (LORE)

C.S.A.: The Confederate States of America

Leave a Comment